Skip to main content

New Trusty Oak is now Nacho! Read the story

Comparison Guide

Nacho vs. Toptal

Two ways to add talent without a full-time hire: one is a global freelance network you hire from and manage yourself, the other is a US-based managed team we run for you. Here's an honest look at how they compare so you can pick the right fit.

A quick overview

The short version.

Toptal and Nacho both help you add experienced talent without committing to a full-time salary, but they work very differently. Toptal is a global, fully remote network of freelancers it describes as the 'top 3%' in business, design, and technology, including developers, designers, finance experts, fractional CFOs, and product and project managers. A client advisor matches you (Toptal cites average matches in under 24 hours) and you hand-pick a freelancer through a no-risk trial, then direct that person yourself. Nacho gives you a managed relationship that flexes from a single executive to a full team of US-based EAs, Specialists, and Executives under one monthly budget, with a dedicated account manager and weekly reporting built in. Below is a side-by-side comparison to help you decide which model fits your needs.

Global freelancers · Self-managed · Rates set per freelancer
Flexible team · US-based · Scalable monthly budget

Run the numbers

Nacho vs. Toptal, head to head.

Criteria
What you get One person or a full team, your choice Individual freelancers you select per role
Who manages the work We do, account management & oversight included You do, you direct the freelancer yourself
Talent location US-based, in your time zone Global, fully remote network
Talent scope Admin to strategic (EAs, Specialists, Executives) Specialized freelancers: dev, design, finance, PM
Pricing model $1,000/mo minimum budget, scale as needed Freelancers set their own rates per engagement
Pricing transparency Minimums published on website Quote-based, no flat rates published
Scaling Flex one budget across multiple talent Source and contract each freelancer separately
Commitment 3 months, then month-to-month Per-engagement; hourly, part-time, or full-time
Getting started Discovery call + custom Delegation Strategy Plan Client advisor match + no-risk trial
Ongoing oversight Weekly reporting + dedicated account manager None, you manage the freelancer directly

Nacho leads in 5 of 10 categories. Want to see how it works for your business?

Book a discovery call

The honest take

Which service fits you better?

Both are legitimate options. The right choice depends on what your business needs.

may be better if…
  • You need an elite, deeply specialized freelancer (like a senior software engineer or a fractional CFO) and you're comfortable directing them yourself
  • You want to hand-pick a specific individual from a large global network and start fast
  • You value Toptal's rigorous screening and want top-tier technical or specialized talent for a defined project
  • You like the no-risk trial model and want to evaluate a freelancer before committing
  • You're fine setting engagements at freelancer-set rates and working across time zones
is the better fit if…
  • You want the option of a single executive AND the ability to scale into a full team, without sourcing each role separately
  • You'd rather we manage the work (account management, oversight, weekly reporting) than direct a freelancer yourself
  • You need a mix of administrative, specialist, and strategic support, not just one specialized freelancer
  • You want US-based professionals in your time zone, with no timezone gaps or language barriers
  • You prefer transparent pricing you can see before any sales call, starting at a smaller monthly budget you can scale
  • You value an ongoing relationship with people who know your business, not a per-project placement

The difference

Why businesses choose Nacho.

A single exec or a whole team.

Need just one strategic operator? Start there. Need admin and specialist support around them? Add it from the same budget. With Toptal you contract each freelancer separately; with Nacho you flex one relationship across as much or as little talent as you need.

We manage it, not just match it.

Toptal matches you with a freelancer you then direct yourself. With Nacho, a dedicated account manager and weekly reporting keep the work on track, so you get outcomes without the management overhead.

Three levels of talent, one budget.

Access EAs, Specialists, and Executives from a single monthly budget. No need to source, vet, and contract separately for admin, creative, or strategic work.

Transparent, flexible pricing.

Start at $1,000/mo and scale up or down as your needs change. Our minimums are published on our site: no quote-by-quote rate negotiation for each engagement.

US-based professionals in your time zone.

Every team member is a vetted, US-based professional working in your time zone. Toptal's network is global and fully remote, which can mean coordinating across time zones. With Nacho there are no timezone gaps or language barriers.

An ongoing relationship, not a placement.

You work with the same people who learn your business over time, not a freelancer you onboard and offboard per project. When you need something, you talk to someone who already has context.

Helping owners & execs

10+ yrs of matching fractional professionals
100% US-based fractional talent network
100K+ hours returned to clients
$10M+ saved through delegation

Ready when you are

Want to see the difference?

Book a free discovery call to learn how Nacho's flexible model can give you a single executive or a full team, without the long-term commitment.

Book a discovery call