New Trusty Oak is now Nacho! Read the story

Comparison Guide

Nacho vs. COMATCH

One matches enterprises with independent management consultants for defined projects. The other runs an ongoing US-based support team for you. Here's an honest look at how they compare.

A quick overview

The short version

First, the thing most comparisons miss: COMATCH no longer trades under that name. Malt acquired it in 2022 and rebranded the network as Malt Strategy, and comatch.com now redirects there. Under that name it is the better fit if you have a scoped consulting or interim-management project and want a senior independent consultant to run it. Malt Strategy screens each consultant's background and interviews them, then hands you a shortlist of three profiles within 48 hours, drawn from a global community of more than 15,000 management consultants and interim executives covering strategy, finance and M&A, operations, transformation, and IT. You review skills, experience, and rates upfront and contract the consultant directly; the platform handles time tracking and invoicing. Nacho is the better fit if the need is ongoing rather than a project, and if it spans more than strategy. One Talent Budget starting at $1,000/mo covers Fractional Executives at $125/hr, Specialists at $65/hr, and Executive Assistants at $40/hr, all US-based, with account management and weekly reporting included. Below is a side-by-side comparison. Both services also appear in our roundup of the best virtual assistant companies.

COMATCH Now Malt Strategy · 15,000+ consultants · Europe-centric · Rates per consultant
Flexible team · US-based · Scalable monthly budget

Run the numbers

Nacho vs. COMATCH, head to head

COMATCH
Company status Operating under its own name Acquired by Malt in 2022, now Malt Strategy
What you get An ongoing team, admin to strategic One independent consultant or interim executive
Engagement shape Ongoing monthly support Scoped project or interim placement
Talent location US-based Global network, strongest in Europe
Talent scope Executive Assistants, Specialists, Executives Management consultants & interim executives
Execution support Included, the same budget covers hands-on work Consulting and interim leadership only
Pricing model $1,000/mo minimum budget + $300 onboarding plan Each consultant's own day rate, quoted per project
Pricing transparency Minimums and rates published on website Rates shown per consultant, no public rate card
Who manages the work We do, account management & oversight included You do, you contract the consultant directly
Speed to match About a week of onboarding Three curated profiles within 48 hours
Typical buyer Founders and small teams Large enterprises like Unilever, L'Oréal, DB Schenker
Minimum spend $1,000/mo, no hour floor Not published; consultant day rates apply

See how a Talent Budget works for your business.

Book a discovery call

The honest take

Which service fits you better?

Both are legitimate options. The right choice depends on what your business needs.

COMATCH may be better if…
  • You have a defined consulting or transformation project with a scope, a deadline, and a budget
  • You need an interim CEO, CFO, CTO, or department head to hold a seat while you recruit
  • You're a large European enterprise and want a consultant who knows that market and its regulations
  • You want the ex-strategy-firm profile: Oliver Wyman, EY, Bain and similar backgrounds, vetted and interviewed
  • You'd rather pick from a shortlist and contract the consultant directly than have a provider manage the work
is the better fit if…
  • Your need is continuing support, not a project with an end date
  • You need administrative and specialist help alongside strategic input, not consulting alone
  • You're a US business and want people in your time zone rather than a Europe-centric network
  • Your budget starts at $1,000 a month, well below a senior consultant's day rate
  • You'd rather we manage the work with weekly reporting than direct a consultant yourself
  • You want published rates you can see before any sales call
  • You want the same people month after month instead of a new brief for every new need

The difference

Why businesses choose Nacho

Built for an ongoing need, not a project

Consulting engagements end. Nacho is a standing team you keep, with the same people learning your business month after month instead of a new brief and a new shortlist each time.

Three levels of talent, one budget

Access Executive Assistants, Specialists, and Fractional Executives from a single monthly budget. No separate sourcing for admin, creative, or strategic work.

Strategy plus the work it creates

A consultant hands you a plan and moves on. Nacho covers the plan and the Specialists and Executive Assistants who carry it out, so the recommendations do not land back on you.

We manage it, not just match it.

Malt Strategy shortlists a consultant for you to direct. With Nacho, a dedicated account manager and weekly reporting keep the work on track without adding to your management load.

US-based professionals

Every team member is a vetted, US-based professional working in your time zone. No timezone gaps, no cultural misalignment, no language barriers.

A floor small businesses can actually reach

Start at $1,000/mo and scale up or down as needs change. Minimums are published on our site, so there's no procurement cycle just to learn what it costs.

Helping owners & execs

10+ yrs of matching fractional professionals
100% US-based fractional talent network
100K+ hours returned to clients
$10M+ saved through delegation

Keep comparing

Compare other services.

See how Nacho stacks up against other virtual assistant options.

Ready when you are

Want to see the difference?

Book a free discovery call to learn how one Nacho Talent Budget covers strategy and the work that follows it, month after month. If the fit isn't right, the Nacho Guarantee means we re-match you for free.